2023-09-30 18:29:00

Robert Powell's Retirement Portfolio: Many young people shouldnt save for retirement, says research based on a Nobel...

Logo MarketWatch
MarketWatch
By Robert Powell

Most financial planners advise young people to start saving early and often for retirement so they can take advantage of the so-called eighth wonder of the world the power of compound interest.

And many advisers routinely urge those entering the workforce to contribute to their 401(k), especially when their employer is matching some portion of the amount the worker is contributing. The matching contribution is essentially free money.

New research, however, indicates that many young people should not save for retirement.

AD
AD

The reason has to do with something called the life-cycle model, which suggests that rational individuals allocate resources over their lifetimes with the aim of avoiding sharp changes in their standard of living.

Put another way, individuals, according to the model which dates back to economists Franco Modigliani, a Nobel Prize winner, and Richard Brumberg in the early 1950s, seek to smooth what economists call their consumption, or what normal people call their spending.

According to the model, young workers with low income dissave; middle-aged workers save a lot; and retirees spend down their savings.

Source: Bogleheads.org

The just-published research examines the life-cycle model even further by looking at high- and low-income workers, as well as whether young workers should be automatically enrolled in 401(k) plans. What the researchers found is this:

1. High-income workers tend to experience wage growth over their careers. And thats the primary reason why they should wait to save. For these workers, maintaining as steady a standard of living as possible therefore requires spending all income while young and only starting to save for retirement during middle age, wrote Jason Scott, the managing director of J.S. Retirement Consulting; John Shoven, an economics professor at Stanford University; Sita Slavov, a public policy professor at George Mason University; and John Watson, a lecturer in management at the Stanford Graduate School of Business.

Continue read on marketwatch.com

AD
Logo Nasdaq
Business / FinanceBy Go Banking Rates2024-09-13 11:02:27
Do you think you know which generation is saving most for retirement ? Findings from a GOBankingRates survey on retirement reveal Gen Z is on track with...

Logo Nasdaq
Business / FinanceBy Go Banking Rates2024-09-26 19:00:05
The average persons retirement fund does not contain millions of dollars.In August 2022, GOBankingRates surveyed 997 Americans on the topic of retirement....

Logo Kiplinger
Business / FinanceBy Jalen Randolph2024-09-06 08:42:05
Getty Images Is it true that many young professionals dont know how to save money? I recently had dinner with an old college friend. I was expecting to catch...

Logo The Motley Fool
MarketsBy Newsfeedback@Fool Com (Catherine Brock)2024-09-20 22:00:48
It may not be easy to save for retirement without a 401(k), but it's also not impossible. According to a study by the Aspen Institute, 55 million Americans...

Logo Nasdaq
MarketsBy The Motley Fool2024-09-12 13:32:40
Image source: Getty Images If you're a salaried employee, you may be entitled to a host of workplace benefits, like subsidized health insurance, paid time...

Logo Nasdaq
Business / FinanceBy The Motley Fool2024-09-21 13:32:34
Image source: Getty Images Many seniors run into financial trouble when they enter retirement without much money in savings and realize their Social Security...

Logo The Motley Fool
MarketsBy Newsfeedback@Fool Com (Christy Bieber)2024-09-20 22:31:38
401(k) accounts are workplace retirement savings plans that employees can contribute to with pre-tax dollars, sometimes receiving matching contributions from...

Logo Nasdaq
Business / FinanceBy Go Banking Rates2024-09-14 22:06:29
Common advice says that its important to start planning for retirement as soon as possible. While you may have opened a retirement savings account in your...

Logo Nasdaq
Business / FinanceBy Due Com2024-09-26 14:00:00
When it comes to retirement, there is no one size fits all approach. For instance, some people have decided to join the F.I.R.E. Movement in order to retire...

Logo Nasdaq
Business / FinanceBy The Motley Fool2024-09-04 12:32:23
Image source: Getty Images You may have the goal of being able to retire comfortably, and also, being able to tackle medical expenses with ease, whether they...

Logo Nasdaq
Business / FinanceBy The Motley Fool2024-09-21 13:00:26
Image source: Getty Images How much should you invest in your 401(k)? If you ask 10 different financial planners this question, you'll probably get 10...

Logo Nasdaq
Business / FinanceBy The Motley Fool2024-09-07 10:36:00
Years ago, when I worked as a salaried employee, I began saving money for retirement in the 401(k) plan my company sponsored. But at this point, I have...

Logo Nasdaq
MarketsBy The Motley Fool2024-09-03 13:32:34
Image source: Getty Images You're probably tired of hearing about it. Save money! Pay down debt! Invest for retirement! There is a reason why as a young...

Logo The Motley Fool
MarketsBy Newsfeedback@Fool Com (Maurie Backman)2024-09-07 10:36:00
Years ago, when I worked as a salaried employee, I began saving money for retirement in the 401(k) plan my company sponsored. But at this point, I have...

Logo Nasdaq
Business / FinanceBy The Motley Fool2024-09-21 12:32:45
Image source: Getty Images It's pretty common for employers -- at least larger ones -- to sponsor a 401(k) plan for retirement savings purposes. And while...

Logo Nasdaq
MarketsBy The Motley Fool2024-09-23 10:00:52
Image source: Getty Images Socking money away in an IRA or 401(k) plan for retirement is an unquestionably good idea. Once you stop working and earning a...

Logo Nasdaq
MarketsBy The Motley Fool2023-09-29 10:32:43
Image source: Getty Images Many people are making retirement investments that could leave them with a huge tax bill in their later years. You may be...

Logo The Motley Fool
MarketsBy Newsfeedback@Fool Com (Adam Levy)2024-09-21 20:59:10
A solo 401(k), also known as an individual 401(k) or a 401(k) with only one participant, is a retirement account available to business owners with no...

Logo Nasdaq
Business / FinanceBy The Motley Fool2024-09-16 12:00:27
Image source: Getty Images A workplace 401(k) can simplify the process of saving for retirement. You get to take an upfront tax deduction for money you...

Logo Nasdaq
Business / FinanceBy Go Banking Rates2024-09-07 21:32:12
If youve got $100,000 in spare cash lying around, you should be invested. Investments are the only way to generate real wealth over time, through the power...